CyberLaw.Info (tm): CyberLaw,  Entertainment Law, Intellectual Property Law, Internet Law and Litigation in Florida. Serving Fort Lauderdale, Boca Raton, Weston, Plantation, Hollywood, Hallandale, Aventura, Delray Beach, Boynton Beach, Pompano Beach, Miami, Broward County, Palm Beach County, and Dade County, Florida. Board Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer. Martindale-Hubbell AV Rating.

Please click

Welcome Guest!      Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page

CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.


CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.

AV Rating

Martindale-Hubbell AV Rating
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.

Recent Articles

· FL Bar Journal
· EASL Section FL Bar
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.

News by Topic

· All topics
· Computer Programs and Scripts (Jan 14, 2011)
· CyberLaw (Jan 06, 2013)
· Emerging Legal Issues (Jun 10, 2012)
· Entertainment Law (Nov 01, 2007)
· Music Law (Oct 20, 2004)
· News (Mar 02, 2012)
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.

Main Menu

· Home
· My Account
· Administration
· Logout

CyberLaw.Info Modules
· AvantGo
· Downloads
· News
· Recommend Us
· Reviews
· Search
· Site Stats
· Topics
· Top List
· Web Links
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.


Your IP:
Browser Info:
CCBot/2.0 (
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.

CyberLaw.Info Tracker

There are no members logged in.
CyberLaw.Info Design Element
You are an anonymous user. You can register for free by clicking here
There are 15 unregistered users
and no registered users on-line
CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.


Bills to curb cyber-bullying raise free-speech concerns
By Elliot Zimmerman on Tuesday, February 05, 2008 - 08:24 AM
By Kathleen Fitzgerald, SPLC staff writer
at 2008 Student Press Law Center
February 4, 2008

Legislators in several states this year have proposed or reintroduced bills to protect students from cyber-bullying, giving school administrators a role in combating what they see as a new wave of electronic harassment. While some feel this will protect students, First Amendment advocates worry the policies will infringe on students' rights.

Craig L. Rice, a Democratic delegate in Maryland, introduced HB199 in January. The bill broadens the definition of bullying to include "any intentional written, verbal, or physical act, including any published communication," that could physically harm an individual, substantially interfere with an individual's education or substantially disrupt the orderly operation of the school.

The bill would require the Maryland State Board of Education to develop standards for investigating complaints of bullying and disciplining individuals who have violated the policy. It also requires the state board to establish a procedure for protecting victims of bullying.

Anti-cyber-bullying bills also are active in Florida, Kentucky, Missouri and Rhode Island.

Alex Grudger, a legislative aide for Rice, said legislative staffers still are working out legal questions such as whether school administrators are allowed to take part in punishing students who bully off-campus, and if so, how this would fit into their disciplinary policies.

"Although many people are interested in [this bill], the legal language has been more difficult than we'd thought," Grudger said.

In Florida, Rep. Nick Thompson's HB669 allows administrators to punish cyber-bullying that happens off-campus as long as it "has the effect of substantially interfering with a student's educational performance, opportunities, or benefits; or has the effect of substantially disrupting the orderly operation of a school."

"It may be an incident that started outside of school online, but when the kids come to school, they continue the bullying," Thompson said.

"The physical location or time of access of a computer-related incident cannot be raised as a defense in any disciplinary action initiated under this section," the bill reads.

States that have passed anti-cyber-bullying legislation include Arkansas, Oregon, Minnesota, South Carolina, Idaho, Washington, Iowa, New Jersey and Delaware.

Arkansas' HB1072, approved in February 2007, prohibits cyber-bullying "whether or not the electronic act originated on school property or with school equipment, if the electronic act is directed specifically at students or school personnel, and maliciously intended for the purpose of disrupting school."

Elliot Zimmerman, a veteran Florida cyberlaw attorney, said schools should not be allowed to get involved in matters outside school grounds. If one student, for example, sues another over slander on MySpace, this is a matter between two individuals and their parents, not the school, he said.

"I don't think schools are equipped to handle these kinds of matters," he said. "As a disruption occurs in school, then they would have the jurisdiction to get involved as it happens ... I would contend that the school had absolutely no jurisdiction."

Zimmerman said schools take on liability if legislators give them this responsibility.

"Imagine if they don't take action." if they miss something. Wouldn't they be opening themselves up for a lawsuit?"

Zimmerman also said these laws might be constitutionally void for vagueness, meaning they are unenforceable because their language is so broad.

Ronald Collins of the First Amendment Center in Washington, D.C., said that although a lot of people use the phrase "cyber-bullying," he is not sure as a legal matter what that means and how it is defined. If it is not defined very narrowly, it is almost sure to raise First Amendment problems, he said.

"Is there a difference between bullying and ranting? Is there a difference between bullying and harassment? Bullying and threats? ... Unless the law is specifically and narrowly defined, it is an abstraction," he said. "When abstractions become law, that is a formula for tyranny."

Student and parental rights should not be abridged by the school off-campus, he said, unless the school is directly affected.

"Is the school going to get involved every time a distraught boy and girl break up?" Collins said.

Some legislators have decided to leave the schools out of their bills. Nicholaus R. Kipke, a Republican delegate in Maryland, introduced a bill that would make cyber-bullying a misdemeanor punishable by a $500 fine & an approach that places responsibility on law enforcement rather than on schools, he said.

Others feel school administrators should be involved, but only to a certain extent.

Justin Patchin, an assistant professor of criminal justice at the University of Wisconsin, and Sameer Hinduja, an assistant professor at Florida Atlantic University, have been researching cyber-bullying for five years. They recommend schools get "informally involved" early on by educating students on respectful Internet use to prevent cyber-bullying.

"It's a very slippery slope. At what point does a matter become so disruptive that the school should get involved?" Patchin said.

CyberLaw.Info Design Element Only.
Related links

CyberLaw Offices

Elliot Zimmerman, P.A.

Attorney At Law
Board Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer

Board Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer

1776 N. Pine Island Road, Suite 224
Plantation, Florida 33322

(954) 565-6996

CyberLaw.Info (tm): CyberLaw, Internet Law, Entertainment Law, Music Law. Board Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer. Rated AV by Martindale-Hubbell. Personal Injury Law, Insurance Law and Litigation. CyberLaw Attorney, Internet Lawyer, Entertainment Lawyer, Music Lawyer, Personal Injury Lawyer, Insurance Lawyer and Litigator Serving Fort Lauderdale, Boca Raton, Weston, Plantation, Hollywood, Hallandale, Pompano Beach, Delray Beach, Boynton Beach, Palm Beach, Aventura, Miami, and Southeastern Florida (Broward County, Palm Beach County and Dade County) since 1981.

cyberlaw, intellectual property law, entertainment law, lawyer, attorney

Law firm licensed to practice law by the State of Florida and the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida since 1981. Board Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer authorized to engage in a multi-jurisdictional federal copyright and trademark practice.

The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. Before you decide, ask us to send you free written information about our qualifications and experience. You may view Mr. Zimmerman's qualifications and experience here.

Not all results are provided, the results are not necessarily representative of results obtained by the lawyer, and a prospective client's individual facts and circumstances may differ from the matter in which the results are provided.

Nothing in this web site should be construed as legal advice to you and does not establish an attorney client relationship between us. You should not rely upon any information contained herein without separate independent legal research and advice. Our law firm is under no obligation to respond to correspondence, including, without limitation, email, until a written retainer agreement is executed. Nothing contained herein should be construed as an endorsement of any and all products or services contained herein or accessible herethrough. By using this web site you agree to abide by our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Advertisement.

Our Designated Agent Under 17 U.S.C. 512(c)(2) to Receive Notification of Claimed Copyright Infringement and Registered Agent to Accept Service of Process is: Mr. Elliot M. Zimmerman, Esq., President of Elliot Zimmerman, P.A., a Florida Professional Association, 1776 N. Pine Island Rd., Ste. 224, Plantation, Broward County, FL 33322, Phone: 954.565.6996, Email:

You may use our CyberLaw.Info RSS News Feed newsfeed to display CyberLaw.Info's news at your site.

© 1995-Present Elliot Zimmerman, P.A.
CyberLaw.Info™ is a Mark of Elliot Zimmerman, P.A.
All Rights Reserved

Page created in 0.024425 Seconds